Lots of hype for the Milburn Review, which was released today. Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, told MPs it was ‘a landmark report setting out a radical blueprint for a new settlement with young people.’ It certainly seems to have gone down well with Labour MPs. That could be because it proposes increases in public spending while some of us are already concerned that spending is spiralling out of control.
Net savings of a mere £200 million are projected to start in 2031/32 on a welfare bill of £431 billion. 13% of young people aged 16 to 24 in the UK are not in education, employment or training. Milburn claims his measures would reduce that to 5%, a level significantly lower than at any point since comparable records began in 2001, which has prompted some scepticism. Robert Colvile regards it as ‘absolutely ridiculous, especially given what politicians have been doing to the youth labour market.’
As Andrew Griffith, the Shadow Chancellor, tweets, it is hardly a mystery that firms overburdened with tax and regulations are reluctant to take the risk of giving the young a job.
Emmanuel Igwe takes up the theme for CapX today. Milburn has accepted the need to ease employers’ National Insurance contributions for under-25s. But how this could be financed is left unclear.
The other main talking point is Andy Burnham’s proposed ‘reset’ with the EU, as sketched out last night at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet. Julian Jessop is unimpressed, declaring on CapX that the reset fails the Prime Minister’s own tests.
Below you’ll find all the latest pieces from CapX, plus what we’re reading from around the web.
Harry Phibbs
Guest Editor, CapX
Today’s Takes
Fresh thinking from CapX
Subsidised jobs are not real, whatever Milburn says
Emmanuel Igwe
‘Having priced young people out, the Government now dangles schemes at them.’
Today Alan Milburn published his review to help reduce the NEETs crisis with almost 1 million 16- to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training. The Milburn Review takes aim at previous government schemes because they were temporary. But subsidised placements only last as long as the subsidy is in place. Milburn’s diagnosis that the National Insurance rise is a significant barrier to youth employment is right but he should go further. Read More
Burnham's reset with the EU fails his own tests
Julian Jessop
‘Outside the Single Market, the UK Government has gained greater freedoms – for good or for ill – to provide more state aid, reduce VAT and “Buy British”.’
The British people voted in 2016 to leave the EU and restore sovereignty to the UK government. However Andy Burnham is preparing for a reset with the EU. He has laid out three tests that any agreement must pass. One test is that it must be consistent with Labour’s 2024 general election manifesto pledge that there would be no return to the single market but the agri-food deal breaches their pledge. The reset similarly fails on the other two tests and would cost the British taxpayers billions. Read More
Stat of the Day
Best of the Web
Find a new strategy or renationalised rail will be a trainwreck
Tony Lodge, The Times 🔒
‘Despite repeated pledges by ministers that a nationalised rail operator would deliver a better and more reliable service, the soaring subsidy, flat income and falling performance risk fatally undermining the whole plan.’
Subsidies for trains and railway infrastructure have reached a record £12 billion a year. But the dire situation is not inevitable. Near-empty London commuter trains are still dominating the Friday timetable when some of these slots could be used by high-demand intercity services. Great British Railways must approve more unsubsidised open-access train competition across the network with more direct fast services. That would be popular with passengers, if not the trade unions. Read More
Labour will reject Milburn's needed welfare reforms
Daniel Herring, City AM
‘As the Centre for Policy Studies has shown recently, the rise in employment costs since Labour came to office is double that of inflation.’
Alan Milburn’s report is calling for tough love in the welfare system. Clearly something is broken when the number of people claiming health and disability benefits outweighs the actual change in sickness and disability. Milburn suggests that young people have a duty to engage or risk losing the rest of their benefits. His suggestions like this one are sensible but it’s unlikely it will get past the parliamentary Labour Party. Read More
Burnham has no other plan than going back into the EU
The Capitalist: Ed Conway – is free trade in retreat?
And if you want more...
– The ridiculous opposition to data centres (The Spectator)
– The economics of Jensen Huang (Marginal Revolution)
– Anti-porn prohibitionism is illiberal (The Critic)
Can we make CapX better?
Or reply to this email to let us know your thoughts.
We'll be back tomorrow.








Millburn’s review is a typical navel gazing, unimaginative odyssey led by the Govt’s inability to contemplate anything that doesn’t get markets approval.
You cannot guarantee jobs or training without significant investment in the economy (away from the rapacious scum in London) and education system.