Just when more of us are turning up the heating, comes the unwelcome news that a typical annual energy bill is predicted to rise by 26% in the new year. This is according to the consultancy Cornwall Insight, an official announcement is due next week. Events in the Middle East have a big impact, but it is still awkward for the Government. Labour promised to cut bills by £300 for an average household, instead it will be paying £870 a year more than when Labour came in.
The Milburn Review dominated todays Prime Minister’s Questions. Kemi Badenoch claimed the Government was offering young people ‘false hope’ by delaying radical welfare reform. Andy Burnham retorted with a new soundbite that the Conservatives offered a ‘cuts-only’ approach. The Government doesn’t seem to offer any cuts to welfare spending for years to come - a point made on CapX by Benjamin Elks.
The Conservative leader also told the Prime Minister that growth comes from business not government, resulting in him complaining she was being ‘patronising.’
As an antidote to the gloom, Mel Stride, writing for CapX, celebrates the benefits to the customer of greater banking competition. Let’s hope the regulators don’t mess it up.
Below you’ll find all the latest pieces from CapX, plus what we’re reading from around the web.
Harry Phibbs
Guest Editor, CapX
Today’s Takes
Fresh thinking from CapX
Banking competition is a UK success story
Mel Stride
‘There is also a competitive opening for the UK, because some of our competitors are stuck. The European Union is still arguing over its own open finance rules, and America’s version has been held up in the courts.’
Open banking is one of the less celebrated economic successes in the UK in the last 10 years. The initiative began in 2017 on the Conservative Party’s watch. The model makes banks compete harder and makes payments cheaper and quicker. The UK model has been used as a blueprint by more than 60 countries. Now John Healey needs to move quickly to bring in the promised regulations for the next stage of open banking by Christmas rather than 2030. Read More
Milburn dodges sensible steps that could cut welfare bill
Benjamin Elks
‘The idea that only £200m can be saved after 10 years and vast amounts of spending is a damning indictment of just how little impact the recommendations will have. Britain’s benefits and spending addiction has run unchecked for too long.’
Alan Milburn rejects ‘crude cuts’ to benefits while calling so substantial up-front spending. His recommendations, if implemented, would save £200 million after 10 years. But this is a measly amount and nowhere near enough to get the benefits bill under control. Andy Burnham promised real solutions to the nation’s problems but if he thinks this Milburn’s report offers that, he’s sorely mistaken. Read More
Stat of the Day
Best of the Web
The unlearned lessons of lockdown
John Redwood, ConservativeHome
‘We did not see senior officials representing the economy or normal life side of the argument, only the health policy side. They were bound to recommend ever stronger and longer lockdowns without much thought for everything else that was endangered.’
The lockdown saw ministers surrendering authority to officials. In the early stages it was to dish out large sums for many people to stay at home and do nothing productive. But the communist-style approach to directing everyone’s lives and movements palled. We face the consequences of the financial excesses. The Cabinet was split over how far the lockdown should go, with the Chancellor pitted against the Health Secretary. Yet Labour did not learn from the experiences that they used to push the Conservatives out of office. Read More
Will the Milburn report be enough to fix a broken welfare system?
Fraser Nelson, The Times 🔒
‘As things stand, Milburn’s changes save almost nothing. His plan is projected to take nine years to break even and will fail to meet his own stated objective of hitting what he calls “Neet-zero” (a Neet rate of 5%). But applying his welfare reform to the whole system would save 10 times more money, move a million people from benefits to work, and pay for itself in closer to five years than 10.’
The report offers a devastating analysis. It is entitled: ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State’. That shows the ambition that is needed. We have a system writing off those it’s supposed to be helping. But the narrow remit he was given means the remedies he offers are far too modest. The challenge for Andy Burnham is to follow the logic of what is required and go much further. Read More
Vienna’s rent controls have been disastrous
The Capitalist: Ed Conway – is free trade in retreat?
And if you want more...
– How hospitals can cut violence (Things Done Well)
– Is Ofgem killing the competition in the energy sector? (Startup Coalition)
– How innovation made the world more colourful (Human Progress)
Can we make CapX better?
Or reply to this email to let us know your thoughts.
We'll be back tomorrow.







