Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Andrew Bowie: How the Tories will smash the energy consensus

The Shadow Energy Secretary on breaking with two decades of energy policy and what the Tories would do instead

‘Every other country in the world that is lucky enough to have an oil and gas basin is expanding that industry. The only country that isn’t, and is laying people off, is this country here.’

This week on The Capitalist, CPS Director Liam Halligan spoke to Andrew Bowie, the Shadow Energy Secretary and Conservative MP for West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine.

Britain has the most expensive energy in the developed world. That cost is hitting investment, growth and household budgets all at once, and the price cap is set to rise again in January. Andrew sets out the Conservatives’ plan to break with the consensus that has held since the Climate Change Act 2008. He says that means scrapping the legal Net Zero 2050 target and stripping the levies and policy costs out of bills.

They discussed the fight over Rosebank now that Jackdaw has been approved. They also cover the energy wealth fund, why the grid is a ‘national embarrassment’ and why Britain’s small modular reactors are taking so long.

Below, you’ll find some longer excerpts from the conversation.

Oscar Gill-Lewis
Deputy Editor, CapX

The most expensive energy in the developed world:

‘Energy is exorbitantly expensive in the United Kingdom. We have the most expensive energy in the developed world, and that is proving such a disincentive to investment by companies here. It’s prohibitive to growth. And when you move on to household bills, it’s doing great damage to the lives and livelihoods of millions of people who don’t qualify for government support and are barely getting by, with the prospect of further price rises around the corner in January… Compare us with the United States, and Texas in particular, the great energy hub of the USA. Energy bills for companies there are on average 25% to 30% cheaper than in the United Kingdom. It’s a no-brainer where you’re going to make your next investment decision.’


Smashing the consensus:

‘The wholesale cost of electricity is only 29% of a household bill. Everything else is taxes, charges, levies and policy costs. People talk about the cost of Net Zero: that is it. And it’s worse if you’re running a business. We need to do something about it, which is why we’re being bold enough to say we’re going to break with the consensus. We’re going to smash the established way of delivering energy in this country, which has held since the Climate Change Act 2008. We’re going to introduce our Cheap Power Plan, which will take away many of these charges and taxes. We’re going to get rid of our Net Zero by 2050 commitment, which will remove the need to invest in some of the technologies that are adding such a burden to bill payers. Nothing’s off the table when it comes to driving down the cost of energy.’


Britain’s global leadership:

‘Every other country in the world that is lucky enough to have an oil and gas basin at its disposal is expanding that industry. The only country that isn’t, and is laying people off, is this country here. We’re surrendering our energy security. We’re surrendering high-paid, high-skilled jobs. And we’re surrendering revenue… The Government’s own impact assessment admitted that the ban on new licences could cost this country £2.5 billion, and that’s at the lower end of the estimates. It will lead to thousands of job losses. But the Labour government have accepted this because they want to show global climate leadership. It’s not leadership if nobody else is following you. No other country in the world is looking at Britain and saying that’s a great way to go about doing business.’


The North Sea isn’t finished:

‘It’s estimated that Rosebank alone could generate £5 billion for the Treasury over its lifetime, and that’s just one field. There are potentially over seven billion barrels of oil and gas equivalent still untapped in the North Sea… I hate this argument that it’s an ageing basin. It’s 140 million years old – of course it’s ageing! But there’s still a future left in it. If there wasn’t, why are the Norwegians expanding exploration in their part of the North Sea? They keep making new discoveries… And the claim that it’s all exported is categorically untrue. All the gas that’s pumped from the North Sea goes straight into the British gas grid, and 80% of homes in Britain are still heated by gas. I’d much rather as much of that as possible was British gas, produced by a skilled British workforce and generating revenue for the British Treasury. As for the oil we do export, every barrel we send to Europe is a barrel they’re not buying from Vladimir Putin.’


How the Tories got it wrong:

‘For the first five years of the 2010s, we had the anvil around our neck that was the Liberal Democrats. Then we had the self-created anvil that was the Brexit wars… In 2019, Parliament and the country were consumed by Brexit. Nobody was really paying attention to anything else. Running alongside that, there were huge demonstrations about climate change and demands that something must be done, and it infected the entire political machine. The problem was that we put Net Zero 2050 into law without any consideration of the economic impact: the cost, what it would mean for bill payers and industry, or what it would mean for Britain’s reputation on the global stage… What have we learned? To stay true to your own beliefs, even when it becomes difficult. Not to allow yourself to be captured by the mood of the moment. And not to set arbitrary dates and targets with no means of reaching them.’


The grid is a national embarrassment:

‘The grid is a national embarrassment, frankly. When I was networks minister, every day MPs would bring in companies from their constituencies trying to get a grid connection, and they were being given dates five, six, seven, sometimes 10 years hence… If you’re Meta or Google or Microsoft looking around the world for opportunities to invest, then for all our problems, we are still an attractive place: the skilled workforce, the legal system, reliability, stability. But then you see you won’t be able to connect your data centre to the grid for a decade. Who in their right mind is going to invest on that basis?… The solution to the energy demands of data centres is small modular reactors. It’s nuclear. SMRs are not going to power the whole of the United Kingdom, but they can be built in strategic parts of the country where you want to site a data centre, providing clean, reliable, continuous power.’

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?